Asda - They provide many products at very competitive prices and a range of goods that are second to none. Dod

Tesco - Simply because they are providing new much needed sports facilities. Clarkthedons

Neither - They kill off local smaller shops, take away community, give very little back to the area in the long run and tend to lead rather than be led (their choice not yours). Look at other towns and what has happened. Hutch

Tesco - I would like to see a larger Tesco store in Banff for the simple reason we already have a very small store, which cannot carry a very wide range of goods. Most people locally shop in the Tesco store and they would all benefit from having a wider range of goods to choose from. At Christmas I usually have to travel to either Elgin or Aberdeen to do my Tesco shopping which in turn means that area gets my custom in other ways. I would rather stay local and do away with the travelling. Likewise, if we had a better store we would get more people into our area and therefore benefit from their custom in other ways. Tesco would be an asset to the town bringing in jobs, full and part-time. There would be other improvements to the area that could be of benefit to the general population. I do not see the need for another large supermarket company in Banff. Susan Clifton

Neither - Sainsbury or Waitrose would be much better! Ann McNaughton

Both - Competition keeps prices competitive. Monopoly is not good for the public's purses. Laure Pecyna